Occam’s Razor and Futures Trading

by Scott Hoffman on June 6, 2011

Over the weekend I got an email from a trader who follows the Taylor Trading Technique as he learned from Linda Raschke.  He asked me whether I use indicators for trading with the TTT and whether I recommended their use (Linda has shown using a moving average oscillator, ADX and ROC among others).  As I was writing a response to him I saw a blog post about applying Occam’s razor to trading.  I am a big proponent of the “simpler is better” school of trading so I thought I’d explain my take on simplifying your trading strategy.

The theory of “Occam’s Razor” is attributed the English monk and logician William of Ockham.  He lived in the late 13th through mid-14th Century.  Although there’s no specific writing of Occam’s razor attributed to him it is commonly accepted that he developed it.

Occam’s razor is said to be the maxim that assumptions introduced to explain a thing must not be multiplied beyond necessity. Another way of putting it is to choose the hypothesis that makes the smallest number of assumptions when hypotheses are equal in other respects.

How does this apply to trading?  In myriad ways it argues to simplify your trading.  This means fewer inputs to your trading decisions.  It could be a smaller number of indicators, less tweaking (curve fitting) of the ones you use, or paying less attention to fundamental factors.

How can you use the Occam’s razor principle?  For some it may be the trading process itself – cleaning your trading space, reducing your inputs while trading (news wires, TV, trading rooms) or trading fewer setups.

For me that’s where the Taylor Trading Technique comes in.  The TTT has a limited use for indicators and I find they can almost always be secondary to the price chart itself.  You may use an indicator to determine where a market appears to be in the TTT cycle but you can stay with price action itself to make trading decisions.  Doing this can allow you to trade off price itself, not more complicated derivations of price.  Understanding the physics of riding a bicycle doesn’t help you get out and ride a bike.

Letting go of complex solutions can be tough for a trader.  Trading is a difficult endeavor, and I think it’s human nature to assume that a difficult problem has to have a complex answer.  There’s also a belief that a trading system can be tweaked or fine-tuned to “solve” the puzzle of trading.  In reality, complicated systems tend to obscure the essence of trading, that trading isn’t “You against the markets, it’s you against you” (to borrow a saying from Ed Seykota).  Occam’s razor may allow you to employ a more robust system that will stand the test of time and give you better market and self – mastery.

This is a sample of the analysis from my Swing Trader’s Insight advisory service. For information on STI, and to sign up for a free two week trial, visit here.

The information contained here includes information from sources believed to be reliable and accurate, but no guarantee is made as to accuracy, nor do they purport to be complete. Opinions are subject to change without notice. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future performance. The risk of loss in trading futures contracts or commodity options can be substantial, and therefore investors should understand the risks involved in taking leveraged positions and must assume responsibility for the risks associated with such investments and for their results.

reader Occams Razor and Futures Tradinggoogle Occams Razor and Futures Tradingdigg Occams Razor and Futures Tradingfacebook Occams Razor and Futures Tradingprintfriendly Occams Razor and Futures Tradingreddit Occams Razor and Futures Tradingtwitter Occams Razor and Futures Tradingtechnorati Occams Razor and Futures Tradingstumbleupon Occams Razor and Futures Tradingshare save 256 24 Occams Razor and Futures Trading
  • Kevin Thomsen

    Great post- simpler IS better. I recall listening to one of Linda’s presentations, and she stressed the point that no TV, newsletters, newspapers or other input is allowed into her trading room. I have laid my trading room our very carefully, even color choices, to make it the most serene and calming room I can.

  • http://www.futuresinsightblog.com Scott Hoffman

    Simplification is part of my motivation for publishing STI. It allows me to write down what I think I need to focus on. Then when I’m going from what I saw last night to looking at the charts the next morning I’ve got succinct ideas as to which markets to home in on.

    It’s kind of counter intuitive but I think as traders get more trading experience their approach often becomes simpler, not more complex.

Previous post:

Next post: